The hostile question

The hostile question

Built to provoke a reaction, not to extract information. Treating it as the second one is the mistake.

CClarke CurranLesson 4 of 814 min

Some questions are designed less to gather information than to produce a reaction — a defensive tone, a visible flash of anger, an unguarded comment — because that reaction is often more useful to a story than any actual answer. Recognising the difference matters, because the two require different responses.

A genuinely hostile or loaded question is usually best handled by naming what it’s doing, calmly, before answering the honest part underneath it: “that framing assumes something that isn’t accurate, so let me correct that first” rather than either accepting the premise or visibly bristling at it.

Try this now. Write the single most aggressive or unfair question you can imagine being asked about your work, and draft a calm, direct response that neither accepts a false premise nor sounds defensive. Read it aloud in as flat and unbothered a tone as you can manage — tone carries as much of this as the words do.

The goal isn’t to win the exchange or to embarrass the person asking. It’s to leave a viewer or reader with your actual position clearly stated, rather than with a memory of you looking rattled.

Clarke Curran

Clarke Curran

Founder & Coach

I've spent ten years coaching executives on how they sound when it counts — in boardrooms, on stage and on camera. One coach, one client at a time.

Work with me

Share